Lecture by Professor Sapna Kumar on 2 November 2026 – Overreach in the U.S. Patent Office: The Collapse of Inter Partes Review
Concerned by how wrongfully-issued patents can harm innovation, the U.S. legislature made it easier for companies to challenge patent validity by creating an administrative procedure known as inter partes review. Faster and cheaper than litigating in federal court, inter partes review petitions seeking cancellations of patent claims surged in popularity. But the current Director of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (Patent Office) has all but shut down the process, asserting ever-expanding discretionary powers to deny meritorious petitions under the U.S. Patent Act. While various companies have challenged the Patent Office’s actions on statutory and constitutional grounds, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (Federal Circuit) claims that it lacks statutory authority to hear such cases. The court’s refusal to intervene has emboldened the current Director to create even more reasons to deny inter partes review petitions, and it has led to the Director denying hundreds of petitions without any explanation.
This lecture will examine the rise and fall of inter partes review, discussing why the Patent Office’s actions are highly problematic for not just innovation, but also for the rule of law. It will highlight how the Federal Circuit’s refusal to intervene is in tension with the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent decisions that have heightened judicial oversight over federal agencies. It further will discuss how the Patent Office’s approach raises troubling constitutional concerns regarding agency overreach.
The event is open to all interested participants, in particular students, PhD candidates, law clerks, practitioners, and academics.
More Information: Link to CIPLITEC
About the Chair
The Chair specializes in intellectual property law (patents, know-how/trade secrets and copyright) and data law. Current research focuses on patent law, in particular on the European Unitary Patent System (UPC), on standard essential patents (SEPs/FRAND) and patent pools in telecommunication and consumer electronics as well as on specific issues of pharmaceutical patents, indirect patent infringement and other topical issues in German, European and International patent law including licensing (see also MUCPAT). Another research focus concerns copyright regulation of the internet as well as legal challenges in the areas of big data, artificial intelligence (AI) and industry 4.0. Furthermore, extensive research projects have covered unfair competition law as well as fundamental questions regarding general principles of intellectual and industrial property rights, such as the treatment of overlap of rights situations. The Chairholder is a member of the Executive Committee of the German Association for Industrial Property and Copyright Law (GRUR), one of three Editors of Germany’s largest Intellectual Property Journal (GRUR journal), a Member of the Editorial Board of GRUR-Patent journal (one of GRUR’s sister journals specifically devoted to patent law) and has authored or edited more than 200 publications in the field including seven books. He has submitted Legal Expert Opinions on German, European and International IP and private law for German and European institutions (such as the European Parliament and other) as well as before German, European, English and U.S courts, arbitration panels and institutions (among them the German Constitutional Court, the German Federal Court of Justice, the Unitary Patent Court, the High Court for England and Wales as well as various U.S. courts and the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC)).
His most recent publications can be found here (PDF, 420 KB) and (partly) here.
Further activities and links
Munich Unified Patent Court Advanced Research Center (MUCPAT)
German Association for Industrial Property and Copyright Law (GRUR)
University Professor
Contact
- Postal address
- Marstallplatz 1
80539 München - Visitors
- Marstallstr. 8 (4. OG)
80539 München - Secretary
- Bettina Wörner
- Phone
- +49 89 2180-71240
- sekretariat.leistner@jura.uni-muenchen.de
Courses in the Winter Semester 2026/2027
Further Information willl be provided by the chair via email.
Further Information willl be provided by the chair via email.
Academic staff
Emeriti
| Name | Tel | |
|---|---|---|
| Lehmann, Michael | michael.lehmann@ip.mpg.de | +49 89 24246-214 |
Former staff
- Freiberk, Carolin
- Harten, Monik
- Hörster, Leonie
- Jussen, Rebecca
- Kleeberger, Dr. Lukas
- Kraus, Dr. Maximilian
- Lersch, Dr. Jan
- Pless, Viola
- Sagstetter, Thomas
- Schäfer, Dr. Oliver
- Schäfer, Stefanie
- Schrom, Korbinian
- Simon, Philipp
- Stadler, Sandra